Back to homepage
CrimeOngoing

Last updated January 12, 2024

The man found in a barrel at Malibu Lagoon

The horrifying summer 2023 case where a body was found inside a barrel at Malibu Lagoon State Beach.

Dateline

Malibu - Los Angeles

Editorial note

Compiled by After the Headline from public reporting, court filings, official records, and the sources cited below.

Current status

Javonnta Murphy was identified as the victim, and two men were charged after his body was found in a barrel at Malibu Lagoon. Public reporting since then has focused mostly on the arrests and on the allegation that the main murder suspect, Joshua Lee Simmons, was later charged in a separate Inglewood killing.

What we know

Javonnta Murphy was identified as the victim, and two men were charged after his body was found in a barrel at Malibu Lagoon. Public reporting since then has focused mostly on the arrests and on the allegation that the main murder suspect, Joshua Lee Simmons, was later charged in a separate Inglewood killing.

What's still unclear

People remember the barrel, but most do not remember that suspects were arrested and that the main suspect was later tied to another killing.

Deep dive

What happened next

The details most readers never saw once the original coverage cycle moved on.

People mostly remember the image: a barrel floating at Malibu Lagoon in summer 2023. The follow-up is darker and much more specific than the average reader remembers. Authorities identified the victim as 32-year-old Javonnta Marshann Murphy. According to investigators and later court reporting, Murphy had been shot in the head before his body was put into a 55-gallon plastic drum and dumped in the lagoon.

The most important development came in October 2023, when the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department announced the arrests of Joshua Lee Simmons and Dennis Eugene Vance. Prosecutors charged Simmons with murder and Vance as an accessory after the fact. The reporting at the time suggested the case was not a random beach horror story at all, but a targeted killing involving people who knew Murphy.

Then the case took another turn that never reached nearly as many people as the original headline. In January 2024, the Los Angeles Times reported that Simmons had also been charged in a separate Inglewood murder. That widened the public-memory gap around the case: many people remembered only the barrel, not that police later tied the same suspect to another homicide.

What still feels unresolved is that the public got the dramatic discovery and then the arrests, but not a widely covered courtroom ending. It is a classic example of public memory freezing at the headline while the later developments fade from view.

Timeline

Key updates

The sequence of major developments, ordered from newest to oldest.

Update

Simmons was charged in a second, separate murder case in Inglewood.

January 12, 2024

Update

Authorities announced arrests of Joshua Lee Simmons and Dennis Eugene Vance.

October 27, 2023

Update

Murphy's body was found in a barrel at Malibu Lagoon State Beach.

July 31, 2023

More to read

Related stories

Other follow-ups readers of this story are likely to want next.

Sources

Reporting and records

4 links